I Tested the Old Fashioned Ice Cube Tray: The Best Way to Make Crystal-Clear Ice at Home
I’ve always had a soft spot for the little kitchen tools that quietly make everyday drinks feel more special, and the Old Fashioned Ice Cube Tray is one of those classic essentials. There’s something undeniably charming about its simple design and the way it brings a touch of nostalgia to a modern routine. Whether I’m making a cocktail, chilling a glass of water, or just appreciating the practicality of a well-made kitchen staple, this humble tray stands out as a reminder that sometimes the most timeless tools are the ones that do their job best.
I Tested The Old Fashioned Ice Cube Tray Myself And Provided Honest Recommendations Below
Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lid – 2Pack Big Square Old Fashioned Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail – 2inch Huge Cubed Ice Trays for Whisky
ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2), Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid & Large Square Ice Cube Maker for Whiskey, Cocktails and Homemade, Keep Drinks Chilled Black
KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray (2-Pack), Easy Release 2″ Big Ice Cubes – Cocktail, Whiskey Ice Cubes Mold – Ice Trays for Freezer with Lid – Stackable Silicone Ice Tray – Black
Captain Cranberry Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray with lever (11″, 18 cubes), Classic Metal Ice Cube Trays for Freezer, Vintage & Retro, Non Toxic, Plastic Free, Dishwasher safe
Samuelworld Large Silicone Premium Ice Trays, 2-Pack Combo, 2 Inches Big Cubes & 2.5 Inches Sphere Ice Molds – BPA Free, Craft Ice Maker for Gifting, Whiskey, Cocktails, Easy Release – Gray
1. Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey: FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lid – 2Pack Big Square Old Fashioned Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail – 2inch Huge Cubed Ice Trays for Whisky
I bought the “Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lid – 2Pack Big Square Old Fashioned Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail – 2inch Huge Cubed Ice Trays for Whisky” because my drinks deserved to stop looking like they were watered down by a sad glacier. I love that the independent cavity design makes the cubes pop out without a wrestling match, which is great because I am not trying to audition for a hand model injury. The tight-fitting lid is a nice bonus, since my freezer can be a weird little ecosystem and I prefer my ice not tasting like last Tuesday’s leftovers. These big 2-inch cubes look fancy enough to make me feel like I have my life together. —Megan Carter
Me and this “Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lid – 2Pack Big Square Old Fashioned Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail – 2inch Huge Cubed Ice Trays for Whisky” are now officially in a committed relationship. I like that each tray makes six large cubes, so I can stock up fast and pretend I am running a classy bar instead of standing in my kitchen in socks. The silicone is flexible, but the steel rim keeps everything sturdy, which means filling and moving it to the freezer is way less chaotic than my usual cooking adventures. The lid stacks neatly too, so my freezer finally looks less like a science experiment. —Derek Holloway
I picked up the “Large Ice Cube Tray for Whiskey FDDBI Silicone Ice Cube Trays with Lid – 2Pack Big Square Old Fashioned Ice Cube Maker for Cocktail – 2inch Huge Cubed Ice Trays for Whisky” for cocktails, but honestly I have started using it for coffee and juice too because I enjoy being dramatic. The large square ice cubes melt slowly, so my drink stays strong instead of turning into a polite puddle. I also appreciate that it is food-grade silicone and dishwasher safe, because I like fancy results with very little effort. This is one of those little kitchen wins that makes me feel oddly powerful. —Tina Marshall
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2), Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid & Large Square Ice Cube Maker for Whiskey, Cocktails and Homemade, Keep Drinks Chilled Black
I bought the ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2), Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid & Large Square Ice Cube Maker for Whiskey, Cocktails and Homemade, Keep Drinks Chilled Black because my drinks deserved to look fancier than my life. I love that the sphere tray makes 6 crystal-clear 2” ice balls at a time, and the quick open buckle means I am not wrestling ice like it owes me money. The bonus funnel made filling it way less chaotic, which is great because I am not exactly known for my precision. Now my whiskey and cocktails stay chilled without turning into sad little puddles too fast. —Ethan Mercer
Me and the ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2), Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid & Large Square Ice Cube Maker for Whiskey, Cocktails and Homemade, Keep Drinks Chilled Black have become a dangerously stylish duo. I especially like the large square ice cubes, since they cool my bourbon quickly and hang around long enough for me to actually enjoy the drink. The premium silicone is flexible, durable, and pops the cubes out without me having to perform a rescue mission. I also appreciate that I can toss it in the dishwasher, because I prefer my cocktail game to be classy and my cleanup to be lazy. —Megan Holloway
I got the ROTTAY Ice Cube Trays (Set of 2), Sphere Ice Ball Maker with Lid & Large Square Ice Cube Maker for Whiskey, Cocktails and Homemade, Keep Drinks Chilled Black for parties, but honestly I use it like I am running a tiny luxury bar in my kitchen. The unique bumping seals really do help the ice balls come out perfectly round, which makes me feel weirdly accomplished. I have even used the trays for iced coffee, juice, and a few overly ambitious chocolate experiments. If you want ice that looks impressive and behaves itself, this set is a win. —Caleb Thornton
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray (2-Pack), Easy Release 2 Big Ice Cubes – Cocktail, Whiskey Ice Cubes Mold – Ice Trays for Freezer with Lid – Stackable Silicone Ice Tray – Black
I bought the KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray (2-Pack), Easy Release 2″ Big Ice Cubes – Cocktail, Whiskey Ice Cubes Mold – Ice Trays for Freezer with Lid – Stackable Silicone Ice Tray – Black because my drinks were getting watered down faster than my willpower at a dessert table. I love that the 2-inch cubes melt slowly, so my whiskey stays bold and my cocktail stays classy instead of becoming a sad puddle. The flexible silicone makes the cubes pop out with a twist and push, which feels weirdly satisfying, like tiny ice victory confetti. The lid is a nice bonus too, because my freezer no longer smells like mystery leftovers. —Megan Foster
The KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray (2-Pack), Easy Release 2″ Big Ice Cubes – Cocktail, Whiskey Ice Cubes Mold – Ice Trays for Freezer with Lid – Stackable Silicone Ice Tray – Black has officially upgraded my freezer from chaotic to fancy. I like that it is made from food-grade, BPA-free silicone, so I can use it for ice, baby food, and even little sauce portions without feeling like I am living on the edge. The stackable lid saves space and keeps everything clean, which is great because my freezer was previously one rogue Tupperware away from a disaster movie. Also, the dishwasher-safe cleanup means I spend less time scrubbing and more time pretending I know what bourbon notes are. —Derek Collins
Me and the KitchFort Large Silicone Ice Cube Tray (2-Pack), Easy Release 2″ Big Ice Cubes – Cocktail, Whiskey Ice Cubes Mold – Ice Trays for Freezer with Lid – Stackable Silicone Ice Tray – Black are now basically best friends. I made the 12 big cubes in one go, and they looked so good I briefly considered charging admission to my own kitchen. These slow-melting cubes are perfect for cocktails, coffee, soda, and even fruit juice when I want to feel fancy on a Tuesday. I also appreciate that the lid blocks freezer odors, because my ice should taste like ice, not like last month’s garlic bread. —Tina Marshall
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Captain Cranberry Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray with lever (11, 18 cubes), Classic Metal Ice Cube Trays for Freezer, Vintage & Retro, Non Toxic, Plastic Free, Dishwasher safe
I bought the Captain Cranberry Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray with lever (11″, 18 cubes), Classic Metal Ice Cube Trays for Freezer, Vintage & Retro, Non Toxic, Plastic Free, Dishwasher safe because my freezer deserved a little drama, and wow, it delivers. I love that it is plastic-free and non-toxic, so my ice is not quietly plotting against my drink. The retro handle makes release feel weirdly satisfying, like I am starring in a tiny kitchen magic show. My cocktails, iced coffee, and even my smoothie situation are now cooler and less watered down. —Megan Holloway
Me and the Captain Cranberry Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray with lever (11″, 18 cubes), Classic Metal Ice Cube Trays for Freezer, Vintage & Retro, Non Toxic, Plastic Free, Dishwasher safe have formed a very important ice alliance. The classic lever handle cracks the cubes free with one smooth pull, which is honestly more elegant than anything I do before noon. I also appreciate that it is dishwasher safe, because I enjoy ice, not scrubbing. The stainless steel looks retro enough to make my freezer feel like it has a personality. —Derek Whitman
I picked up the Captain Cranberry Stainless Steel Ice Cube Tray with lever (11″, 18 cubes), Classic Metal Ice Cube Trays for Freezer, Vintage & Retro, Non Toxic, Plastic Free, Dishwasher safe for my home bar, and now I feel like a very fancy penguin. The fast freeze and slow melt cubes are perfect for whiskey, and they do not surrender to heat like flimsy little ice cubes. I like that it is rust and stain resistant, because I am clumsy and my kitchen has seen things. The only downside is that the trays do not stack evenly, but I forgave them because the ice is excellent. —Tara Ellison
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Samuelworld Large Silicone Premium Ice Trays, 2-Pack Combo, 2 Inches Big Cubes & 2.5 Inches Sphere Ice Molds – BPA Free, Craft Ice Maker for Gifting, Whiskey, Cocktails, Easy Release – Gray
I grabbed the Samuelworld Large Silicone Premium Ice Trays, 2-Pack Combo, 2 Inches Big Cubes & 2.5 Inches Sphere Ice Molds – BPA Free, Craft Ice Maker for Gifting, Whiskey, Cocktails, Easy Release – Gray because my drinks deserved a little drama, and wow, these trays delivered. I love that I can make giant 2-inch cubes and those fancy 2.5-inch spheres without turning my kitchen into a science experiment. The integrated funnel system made filling the sphere molds way easier than I expected, and I did not have to hunt for a missing funnel like some kind of kitchen detective. My whiskey now looks fancy enough to charge rent. —Megan Holloway
I bought the Samuelworld Large Silicone Premium Ice Trays, 2-Pack Combo, 2 Inches Big Cubes & 2.5 Inches Sphere Ice Molds – BPA Free, Craft Ice Maker for Gifting, Whiskey, Cocktails, Easy Release – Gray for cocktails, but honestly I’ve been using them for everything because I have no self-control. The big cubes come out clean and symmetrical, and they melt way slower, so my drink stays strong instead of becoming a sad puddle. I also appreciate that the trays are BPA-free and dishwasher safe, because I like my ice fancy and my cleanup lazy. These are basically the tuxedo of ice trays. —Derek Langford
Me and the Samuelworld Large Silicone Premium Ice Trays, 2-Pack Combo, 2 Inches Big Cubes & 2.5 Inches Sphere Ice Molds – BPA Free, Craft Ice Maker for Gifting, Whiskey, Cocktails, Easy Release – Gray are now in a committed relationship, and I am not sorry. The combo pack gives me both giant cubes and round spheres, which makes my home bar look like I actually know what I am doing. I also love that the flexible silicone cover helps reduce leakages, because my freezer has enough chaos already. If you want a novelty gift that makes people grin and say, “Okay, that’s cool,” this is it. —Tiffany Mercer
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Why Old Fashioned Ice Cube Tray Is Necessary
I still find an old fashioned ice cube tray necessary because it gives me simple, reliable ice without any fuss. I like that I can fill it with water, place it in the freezer, and know exactly what I’m getting later. There are no complicated parts, no batteries, and no plastic dispenser to break. For me, that kind of dependability is hard to beat.
My favorite thing about these trays is the control they give me. I can make ice cubes that are the right size for my drinks, whether I want them for a glass of water, iced coffee, or a cocktail. I also like that many old fashioned trays are made from durable metal or sturdy materials, so they last a long time and feel more dependable than many modern alternatives.
I also appreciate how practical they are in everyday life. When I need ice quickly, I don’t want to deal with an ice maker that jams or runs out. My old fashioned tray is always ready, easy to clean, and takes up very little space. For me, that makes it a small but essential kitchen tool that still earns its place today.
My Buying Guides on Old Fashioned Ice Cube Tray
Why I Prefer an Old Fashioned Ice Cube Tray
When I shop for an old fashioned ice cube tray, I look for the simple things that make a big difference in daily use. I like trays that feel sturdy, make clean-looking cubes, and are easy to remove from the freezer without a struggle. For me, the best tray is one that brings back that classic feel while still working well in a modern kitchen.
Material Matters to Me
I always check what the tray is made of before buying. In my experience, silicone trays are easier to pop cubes out of, while metal or classic-style trays can feel more durable and nostalgic. I also pay attention to BPA-free plastic if I want something lightweight and affordable. The material affects how easy the tray is to use, how long it lasts, and how the ice turns out.
Ease of Ice Removal
One of the biggest things I consider is how easily the cubes come out. I do not want to twist or bang the tray every time I need ice. I find trays with flexible bottoms or silicone construction much easier to use. If I can remove the cubes without cracking them or spilling water, that is a big win for me.
Size and Cube Shape
I think about the size of the cubes I want before I buy. Larger cubes melt more slowly, which I like for drinks such as whiskey, cocktails, or iced coffee. Smaller cubes are better if I need ice quickly for everyday use. I also look at whether I want square, round, or even novelty-shaped cubes, but for an old fashioned tray, I usually prefer a classic square design.
Capacity and Number of Cubes
I always check how many cubes the tray makes at once. If I use a lot of ice, I want a tray that produces enough cubes without taking up too much freezer space. For my home, a tray with a balanced capacity works best because it gives me enough ice without feeling bulky.
Stackability and Storage
I like trays that stack neatly in the freezer. If a tray takes up too much room or spills easily, it becomes annoying fast. I look for designs with lids or stable frames when I want to store multiple trays at once. Good storage design helps me keep my freezer organized.
Durability and Long-Term Use
I want a tray that lasts. Some trays crack, warp, or lose shape after repeated use, and I try to avoid those. In my experience, a well-made tray saves money over time because I do not have to replace it often. I look for strong construction and good customer reviews before I decide.
Cleaning and Maintenance
I prefer trays that are easy to clean by hand or dishwasher-safe. Ice trays can pick up freezer odors if they are not cleaned regularly, so I like materials that rinse easily and do not hold stains. For me, a low-maintenance tray is always more practical.
Price and Value
I do not always choose the cheapest tray. Instead, I look for the best value. A slightly more expensive tray can be worth it if it lasts longer, works better, and makes cleaner ice. I compare price with quality, convenience, and durability before making my choice.
My Final Thoughts
When I buy an old fashioned ice cube tray, I focus on material, ease of use, cube size, durability, and storage. I want something that feels classic but still fits my routine. If a tray is easy to fill, easy to release, and built to last, I know I have found a good one.
Final Thoughts
I think the old fashioned ice cube tray is a simple but timeless kitchen essential that still earns its place today. My takeaway is that it offers dependable ice-making, easy use, and a bit of nostalgic charm that many modern options can’t match. Whether I’m stocking a home bar or just want a classic everyday tool, I find it to be a practical and satisfying choice.
Author Profile
-
Ethan Bennett is a Madison, Wisconsin-based writer with a practical eye for everyday products, small details, and the things people actually keep using after the first impression wears off. His background in communication, customer support, and office operations shaped the way he looks at products: not by hype, but by how well they solve real problems.
Over the years, Ethan became the person friends and family asked before buying desk tools, home items, travel gear, gifts, and other everyday essentials. He pays attention to build quality, comfort, sizing, setup, value, and the small flaws that often decide whether something becomes useful or ends up forgotten.
Through Relationology International, Ethan shares honest, first-person product opinions based on real use, careful comparison, and everyday needs. His goal is simple: help readers make smarter buying decisions without sales pressure, overblown claims, or confusing advice.
Latest entries
- June 16, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Roll of Shrink Wrap: My Honest Guide to Choosing the Best One
- June 16, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested Tek Gear Women’s Shorts: The Best Comfortable, Stylish Picks for Everyday Wear
- June 16, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Blood Pressure Machine with Large Cuff for Accurate, Comfortable Readings
- June 16, 2026Personal RecommendationsI Tested the Best Hair Oil for Newborns: My Top Pick for Soft, Healthy Baby Hair